M/S Godrej Sara Lee Limited v. Reckitt Benckiser Australia Pty.Ld.

Simon, S. A. U.vsThe Controller Of Patent & Designs & Anr.

Simon filed three applications for the registration of a design related to 'Accessories For Electrical Devices', claiming priority from a Spanish application. The Controller found that the design lacked novelty because it was taught by earlier, prior published designs and compared unfavorably with Registered Design No. 216507.

J.N. Electricals (India)vsPresident Electricals

J.N. Electricals sued President Electricals for infringing their registered design of an electric toaster, passing off, and copyright piracy of their promotional pamphlets. The court found that the defendant's toaster was deceptively similar to the plaintiff's registered design, and the defendants had outrightly copied the plaintiffs' pamphlet word-for-word.

Symphony LimitedvsRaj Cooling System Private Limited

Symphony Limited filed a suit against Raj Cooling System Private Limited alleging infringement of its registered design (No. 288184) for air coolers. The dispute was settled amicably between the parties, leading to the court disposing of the suit.

Nec CorporationvsThe Controller Of Patents And Designs

The appeals challenged the rejection of various applications seeking to register GUIs as industrial designs. The appellants argued that the Controller adopted an unduly strict interpretation, failing to recognize GUIs as registrable designs under the Designs Act, 2000. The Court held that the respondent authorities failed to apply the correct legal tests regarding GUI registration.

Brighto Auto IndustriesvsRaj Chawla (Messrs B.Chawla & Sons)

Brighto Auto Industries filed a petition to cancel the design registration (No. 139585) held by Raj Chawla's firm for rear view mirrors, arguing that the design lacked novelty and originality as it was common in the market. The court examined whether the minor modification made by the respondent constituted a new or original design.